ICC Prosecutors Urge Judges to Reject Duterte Defense Challenge Over Undisclosed Evidence

 

International Criminal Court (ICC) prosecutors are asking judges to dismiss a procedural challenge filed by former Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte's defense team, arguing that its attempt to contest undisclosed material is premature and does not follow established court procedures.

The dispute centers on a request seeking a ruling in limine, a legal mechanism used to resolve issues before evidence is formally presented during trial. Prosecutors maintain that Duterte's lawyers cannot seek such a ruling through procedural observations when the contested material has yet to be submitted to the judges as evidence.

Details of the disagreement appeared in a four-page public filing dated November 20. Much of the document was redacted, preventing public disclosure of the specific material under dispute and the precise arguments raised by both sides.

The prosecution initially submitted its response confidentially on November 13, following observations from Duterte's defense team and the Common Legal Representatives of Victims. These submissions were requested by Trial Chamber III.

Although prosecutors declined to take a position on the broader issue before the chamber, they objected to what they described as an attempt by the defense to go beyond the scope of the court's instructions.

They also argued that the request violated the ICC's Rules of Procedure and Evidence, along with the chamber's established protocol governing challenges to the admissibility of evidence.

At the center of the prosecution's argument is Rule 64(1), which requires parties to raise objections concerning the admissibility of evidence when the material is submitted to the chamber. This means the defense must wait until prosecutors formally introduce the contested material before challenging its admissibility.

According to the prosecution, using procedural observations to obtain an advance ruling would bypass the prescribed process.

Prosecutors also sought to correct what they characterized as an inaccurate submission by the defense. However, the relevant statements and the prosecution's explanation were redacted in the publicly available document.

The prosecution ultimately asked Trial Chamber III to reject the defense's request for a preliminary ruling, maintaining that any admissibility concerns should be addressed at the appropriate stage of the proceedings.

Duterte's Crimes Against Humanity Trial Begins November 30

The procedural disagreement comes as Duterte prepares to face trial at the ICC over allegations of crimes against humanity involving murder and attempted murder.

Proceedings are scheduled to begin on November 30 at 10 a.m. in The Hague, Netherlands, corresponding to 5 p.m. Philippine time.

At the opening of the trial, judges will establish whether Duterte understands the charges against him and ask him to enter a plea of guilty or not guilty.

The proceedings will follow an earlier determination by Trial Chamber III that Duterte is fit to stand trial and capable of effectively exercising his rights under international fair-trial standards.

The upcoming hearings mark a significant stage in the ICC proceedings, with the court set to begin examining the allegations against the former Philippine leader.

Comments